These are the NPCs and former PCs adopted by Veronica during the duration of the podcast listed by their season of first appearance/mention.
Season One[]
- Roger Martin V
- Nyarlathotep
- Nancy Patricia Caldwell
- Vaeda Forsythe
- Erik Miller
- Jack Thompson
- Warren Mason
- Edward Mason
- Officer 42
- The Dog
- Officer O'Malley - Handling the "missing boy" case that Vaeda used to escape custody from the St. Paxton police in Episode One. Presumed dead.
- Rory Forsythe - Vaeda's brother who died at the St. Paxton School for Boys.
- Sarah Goodwin - A young girl who has gone missing on Monhegan Island.
- Alan Krebs - Roger Martin's butler, surprisingly badass. Nyarlathotep's first body which he used to leave Monhegan.
- Angela and Brandy - The Twins that Roger Martin adopted after their mother's untimely death.
- Darius - in Xander's research, Darius is revealed to have been the one to contain the Outer Gods. Responsible for imprisoning and submerging them, and banishing Nyarlathotep to Monhegan.
- Officer O'Kelley - Questions Xander Cain upon his arrest/return from Monhegan.
- Officer O'Brien - Questions Vaeda Forsythe upon her arrest/return from Monhegan.
- Calvin Dodson - Professor at Boston U who hired Xander to obtain the Necronomicon from Roger Martin on Monhegan.
Season Two[]
- Officer 13
- Mary Mason
- Randall
- Rob
- Tes
- Max
- Herbert West
- The Bird
Season Three[]
Season Four[]
- Officer Darby
- Amy
- Mona, Leonard's love interest. May be a figment of our imaginations.
- Elizabeth, Mona's daughter.
- Judy, Steve Hill's wife.
- Danny, Steve's youngest son.
- Jake, Steve's eldest son.
- Sasha, Frank McFarney's wife.
- Eliza, Frank's daughter.
- Nancy Patricia Caldwell
Season Five[]
Season Six[]
- Marie
- 42
- Mary Mason
Bird Arc - Season One[]
- Beatrice Mason - magistrate of justice of SPI
- Carol Becker - missing teenager
- Clark - one of the brothers who rows the boat to and from Monsato Lago
- Clem - a dog
- Darius Hemsley - best friend of the four player characters
- Devin Caldwell - Patty's son, sails the ferry to and from SPI
- Diane Becker - mother of missing girl Carol Becker
- Ezra - the librarian
- Henry - one of the brothers who rows the boat to and from Monsato Lago
- Leo - owner of the Divine Bovine
- Lily - a bird with strange markings on her beak
- NightHawk - personal assistant to the mayor
- Patty Caldwell - manager of the SPI visitor center and local radio host
- Ruby Stanley - Darius's assistant
- Tess - works at the lab in the police station